This post has already been read 2156 times!
Readers who follow my bi-weekly post know my blogging routine and topics quite well. Mondays are for posts to reduce stress, manage time and career related subjects. The weekend is a reflective spiritual/metaphysical nature post. I write from the heart for that is where my soul resides. There are of course other issues that give me concern but do not fit into the nature of my blog.
So when Angela Goodeve posted on her blog Life Coaching Advice with Ang about Blog Action Day and the theme of “The Power of We”, I could not resist the opportunity to write about an issue of concern and be a part of something bigger than myself. It nourishes my soul to be able to bring a societal issue and the preventive actions already being taken to my readership and a wider audience through the platform of Blog Action Day.
Yet more needs to be done as part of a collective consciousness. May this post inspire you to join me in bringing back values that count and repairing any holes in the fabric of society to preserve our old age assurance that family really means family and is not a figment of an aged mind’s imagination.
For Blog Action Day, I have chosen to write about the subject of Elder Abuse and HelpAge India’s endeavors to raise social awareness of this phenomenon and their actions to help a section of society protect itself and restore their sense of self-esteem is commendable.
Why did I choose to write about Elder Abuse?
We cannot generalize that all children dare to abuse or ill-treat their aged parents but it is also a fact that there are some folks out there doing exactly what the majority would not dream of doing as witnessed from the HelpAge Elder Abuse Study 2012. My focus is on India but the report is international in its coverage. It is something to think about.
I would like to believe that the study has highlighted exceptions to the rule. Perhaps the sample collected might be a factor in the results recorded and which might not hold on extrapolation but please consider that there is legislation for maintenance of parents in India and when The Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007 was made effective, I admit I was surprised that we needed legislation for something that was taken for granted in the Indian family tradition.
The Act applies to the whole of India except for the State of Jammu and Kashmir and is applicable to all citizens even those outside of India. It was enacted for more effective provisions for the maintenance and welfare of parents and senior citizens guaranteed and recognised under the Constitution of India. The Act has been has been notified by 23 States and all Union Territories with States of Manipur, Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, Meghalaya and Sikkim yet to notify the Act. Amazing as it sounds, only 4 States, namely, Gujarat, Madhya Pradesh, Tripura and West Bengal have taken all necessary steps.
I remember asking my mother, why we need such legislation. Is it not implicitly understood that the person whose index finger you held as a child and who sheltered and nurtured you till you could look after yourself should be given a full hand to hold in their elderly years when they need it? Mother agreed with me but mentioned that there were reports of crimes against elderly people and other matters on the television news channels while I was out at work.
I asked the same question of an Executive Search firm Director in conversation and his response left me bewildered. According to him, abandoning parents in their old age was okay since one had to look after ones family and cost of living was high. What do you say to a highly educated and credentialed professional? Well I did tell him that in a few years, he would be on the other side of the fence and these thoughts might be applied by his children. Whatever happened to family values?
Fortunately all my close friends are in the same boat of being caregiver to one or both parents and we are happy to have them around. Some of my friends have 3 generations living under the same roof and the elderly parent is as valuable for advice and keeping the family support systems well-oiled and in top gear.
On the other side of the spectrum, there is a harsh reality in a country like India where abuse against the elderly is rarely talked about. When domestic violence and dowry deaths were being reported in the news, I asked my late father whether these were new phenomenon. His sagely remark was that these social atrocities do not happen overnight. Perhaps they have always existed and it is only now that women are coming out and speaking about it. I think it is the same with more & more elderly citizens finding the courage to come out in the open, talk to media and highlight what is an extremely sensitive, closeted and complex phenomenon: Elder Abuse.
This phenomenon needs to be taken seriously if you consider the findings in the UNFPA and HelpAge International report on “Ageing in the Twenty – First Century: A Celebration and A Challenge” released on October 1, 2012.
The Report includes HelpAge India’s 2012 study on Elder Abuse in India.
Each year, HelpAge India, a charity working for the country’s elderly focuses on this issue and has driven home the importance of safety and security of our elders with their reports. On June 15, 2009, HelpAge India raised its voice against this heinous crime on “World Elder Abuse Awareness Day”. Their activities for garnering support for the cause and raising awareness about the issue was done through concrete mediums of rallies, signature campaigns, and interactive discussions between senior citizens, policy makers, decision makers, police and media representatives. The day was marked in Delhi, Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka, West Bengal, Goa, Maharashtra, Madhya Pradesh, Gujarat & Haryana.
This year, on the eve of “World Elder Abuse Awareness Day (June 15)” HelpAge India revealed some startling facts through its nationwide report on “Elder Abuse in India” with a sharp focus on the role of family. The report was released by Lieutenant Governor of Delhi, Mr. Tejendra Khanna today at the India International Centre. Special guest, Mr. Amulya Patnaik, Special Commissioner of Police, Law & Order (Delhi) also gave some relevant insights on the issue.
The report spanned 20 cities: Delhi, Mumbai, Kolkata, Bangalore, Hyderabad, Guwahati, Patna, Chandigarh, Panaji, Ahmedabad, Shimla, Jammu, Kochi, Bhopal, Bhubaneswar, Puducherry, Jaipur, Chennai, Dehradun, & Lucknow. 5600 elders across India were interviewed with 280 per location (of which 5400 responses were found valid).
The main findings would make anyone wonder whether the happy family soap operas aired on prime time television and shown in Bollywood movies might soon become a part of imagination or that those of us who are caring for the elderly will be analysed as aberrant, put on medication and be the subject of a Minority Report in the decades to come.
Here are some facts, taken directly from the report:
- 31% of older persons reported facing abuse.
- More than half of those abused were facing it for more than 4 years and all these were facing multiple forms of abuse.
- 24% older people faced abuse almost daily.
- 75% of those who faced abuse lived with family and 69% were owners of the house in which they were living.
- The primary abuser was the son in 56% cases, followed by the daughter-in-law with 23% cases.
- More than 50% of those abused, had faced this situation for more than 5 years. 33% faced it for up to 3 years and less than 1 % faced it for more than 6 years.
- 55% of those abused, did not report it to anyone. 80% (approx.) of these did not report the matter to uphold family honor.
- 62% older persons suggested the most effective mechanisms to tackle Elder Abuse was sensitization of children and strengthening of inter-generational bonding and 38% stated it to be economic independence.
- 18% older persons did not know about any of the currently available redress mechanisms. 36% knew about one and 46% knew two or three of the options.
- The older persons considered disrespect, neglect and verbal abuse as Elder Abuse.
- Disrespect, followed by neglect and verbal abuse, were thought to be the form in which Elder Abuse was most prevalent in our society.
- 6% older persons did not know what constitutes Elder Abuse.
- 81% older persons thought that Elder Abuse was prevalent in our society.
- Only 22% older persons considered the prevalence rate of Elder Abuse in society to be high; an equal proportion considered it to be low and 56% said it was moderate.
- Most of the abused older persons experienced disrespect; neglect and verbal abuse .
- Little less than 50% of the older persons had seen cases of Elder Abuse in their surroundings
- Out of those who reported abuse, 49% elders chose a family member for reporting/ confiding about it.
- Police Helplines and services were known to majority of the respondents but were never used, probably due to lack of trust or to maintain family honor.
- Delhi NCR witnessed a rise in abuse from last year, with 29.82% elderly stating they faced abuse, as against 12% the year before. Mumbai (Maharashtra) followed a close second to Delhi NCR with 29.46 %.
- Bhopal (MP) ranked the highest in Elder Abuse with 77.12% elders stating they faced abuse, followed closely by Guwahati (Assam) with 60.55% and Lucknow (UP) with 52%.
- Other than Bhubaneswar (Odisha) with 23.31%, Eastern India on an overall basis had high percentage of Elder Abuse with Guwahati(Assam) – 60.55% & Kolkata (WB) – 40.93% .
- Jaipur (Rajasthan) reported a miniscule 1.67% cases of Elder Abuse.
- 11% of older women and 6% older men did not have any knowledge about the currently available reporting and redress mechanisms. None of the respondents knew about all the available mechanisms.
- 19% older women knew about one mechanism as compared to 17% men, and 21% women knew 2 or 3 mechanisms as compared to 25% older men.
A quick intercity comparative graph on existence of Elder Abuse in India (%)
HelpAge India Recommendations
The Hindu scriptures tell us that it is a sin to hurt others, but it is a bigger sin to allow others to hurt us. Perhaps in their twilight years, these senior citizens feel that they cannot turn back the clock and do things differently, but their wisdom to protect the future generations from their own fate shines through in the recommendations that HelpAge India has put down based on the views of these elderly citizens:
- There should be nationwide programs in schools and colleges for sensitizing the children towards ageing and aged. HelpAge has been working towards this through its Student Action for Value Education (SAVE) Programme which aims at Inculcating values of care & respect for the elderly in school going children, Prepares today’s children & youth for their old age and creating an age friendly society.
- A robust social security system that not only ensures income security for the elderly, but also gives them opportunities for income generation.
- Involvement of society at large in prevention of Elder Abuse.
HelpAge India’s role here is one of an enabler between two groups of people. Their recommendations, many of which I have actually seen being implemented include
- A comprehensive security audit for senior citizens homes.
- An inspector in each of the 130 stations in the city to be put in charge of this drive who will be the nodal officer who will prepare the audit report and inform the district DCP’s.
- All police stations have been instructed to ensure that seniors are not harassed by property dealers and land sharks.
- The police will help senior citizens to install basic security equipment like door chains, magic eye, safety locks, iron grills etc. by liaisoning with the contractors for the equipment.
- A major focus will be on servant verification with the aim to verify 80% of domestic help by end of drive.
But this isn’t just about Elder People or HelpAge. It is about us as a generation. It is about what we believe in and what steps we take to set a good example to the younger generations about the meaning of family.
Many of us sign petitions on the internet to express our outrage at cruelty to animals and participate in candle light vigils to ensure that high profile personalities accused of rape, murder or abetting suicide do not escape punishment.
It is equally important to take active steps within the confines of our homes and communities to prevent this mind boggling virus called Elder Abuse from invading our social psyche and the loss of a civilization so lovingly handed to us by our forefathers. If 88% of respondents in the study did not report the abuse to uphold family honour, then let us take steps to ensure that next time the study is done, 88% will report that their children treat them the way they would expect the family elder to be treated – with respect, love and a sense of belonging.
Pass the baton on the way you received it in the human relay race. Do not drop it or let it chip. The future of mankind depends on the actions we take today.
I am grateful for support from Umang Singh of HelpAge India who provided me with the statistics and details from Elder Abuse Report for 2012 appearing in the blog post and urge the reader to visit their website and support their initiatives. I do.
About HelpAge India
HelpAge India is a leading charitable organization working with and for older people in India for the past 34 years. It runs age care programs throughout the country and advocates strongly for the cause of the elderly and fights for their rights. It also advises and facilitates the Government in formation of policy related to the elderly.
Posts
I adhere to the Certified Coaches Alliance Code of Ethics and Standards. A copy is available on request.
Email:
Vatsala, this is an amazing post, and is a topic close to my heart as I have a Grandmother who is one of the most important and special people in my life. It is unimaginable that she would ever go through something like this.
The statistics are shocking, and these are only the cases that are known of in the studies.
My prayers are with anyone who has been victim to these atrocities. Let use the #powerofwe and share positive energy for a world where everyone is treated with the love, respect, and dignity they deserve!
I have to admit that I was close to tears a few times reading this article, and you have shown once again just how deserving you are to win first place in the 2012 Best Coaching Blogs contest!
Peace and love to you!
Vatsala, this is a touching post, and a topic close to my heart as my Grandmother is one of the most important and special people in my life, and it is just unthinkable that she may experience something like this. The statistics are shocking, and these are only of the cases that are known!
I have to admit that I was close to tears reading your heartfelt words, and my thoughts and prayers go out to all of the innocent souls that have experienced these atrocities.
Let us all focus our energy, and use the #powerofwe to imagine a world where everyone is treated with dignity, respect, and love that they deserve!
Peace and Love to you…you have shown once again just how deserving you were to win first place in the 2012 Best Coaching Blog Contest!
Dear Angela, I can relate to what you are writing. I was stunned to read the Report but wanted to use my outrage for a positive cause and here you have been an instrument of Fate to make my wish materialize when I read your post about Blog Action Day!
After that, everything fell into place with HelpAge India giving me copies of reports and all I had to do was write from my heart.
Thank you for the wonderful words about my Blog win. In all humility it would not have been possible for a newbie blogger to win against super bloggers without the readers and the finalist bloggers who voted for me! An example of the manifestation that you wrote about in your blog? 🙂
Vatsala, this is an amazing post, and is a topic close to my heart as I have a Grandmother who is one of the most important and special people in my life, and it is unimaginable that she would ever go through something like this.
The statistics are shocking, and these are only the cases that are known of in the studies.
My prayers are with anyone who has been victim to these atrocities. Let use the #powerofwe and share positive energy for a world where everyone is treated with the love, respect, and dignity they deserve!
I have to admit that I was close to tears a few times reading this article, and you have shown once again just how deserving you are to win first place in the 2012 Best Coaching Blogs contest!
Peace and love to you!
Thank you for writing in and being supportive of people who need you, even if you are across the Atlantic Ocean. This is exactly the one step in the right direction that I am thinking about.
The Report was an eye opener for me too. Sadly, we are often hurt most by the very people we would not expect to hurt us.
This is an eye-opening post, Vatsala. Just yesterday I drafted a letter from Paris to a doctor in the U.S. that is an appeal to help her find a diagnosis and treatment for an ailment that has plagued her for over 10 years. Though I live far away, I do all that I can to support her. It is incredible that we even need to talk about such a thing as elder abuse and neglect, yet it is a sad fact of life.
The UNFPA and HelpAge International Report indicated that this is global phenomena. That is disturbing, since one would not expect countries famous for their family systems like India, Ghana or Brazil to feature in the disturbing statistics.
I agree that Mayors and Councillors can make a difference provided they are committed to social change and not making promises to capture the vote bank.
In the meantime, we the people can make a difference in our own way. One step in the right direction starts a journey.
Enio, would it be possible to post an English translation too on your blog? I would love to read your post!
Unfortunately, in my country, the elderly are often considered a dead weight that the family should load. Often they are left in asylums and institutions without the least resources to have at least dignity. I think that is a problem not only in India, but much of the world.
My view on the subject was more to the aspect of politics, based on the elections for mayors and councilors taking place this month in Brazil. If you can, visit my page.